Catching up with my reading
Amazing what you can fit into a few days when the OU offices are shut & there's no marking to do....
Have finally read Lynne Truss's Eats, Shoots & Leaves, the punctuation best-seller. I liked that a lot & can quite understand why it became so popular. It treats dry topics such as semi-colons & misplaced apostrophes with the kind of fervent levity you would normally associate with newsgroups/blogs - in short, a web writer's voice addressing a bookish subject (in a book, of course....).
Then tonight I got halfway through David Weinberger's Small Pieces Loosely Joined (his follow-up to The Cluetrain Manifesto). That's good fun too, on a much broader canvas. A philosophy teacher turned software marketer turned web theorist, he takes a bunch of Big Concepts (time, space, that sort of stuff) & looks at how the web gives them an alternate meaning.
My favourite chapter so far is Perfection, where he argues persuasively & humourously that the web's 'brokenness' is its strength: its flaws are precisely what make it human & therefore attractive, overcoming corporate glossiness, political correctness & all the other little strategies used in the 'real world' to cover up our deep embarassment at failing to achieve perfection. Weinberger says it all far better than my summary!
Have finally read Lynne Truss's Eats, Shoots & Leaves, the punctuation best-seller. I liked that a lot & can quite understand why it became so popular. It treats dry topics such as semi-colons & misplaced apostrophes with the kind of fervent levity you would normally associate with newsgroups/blogs - in short, a web writer's voice addressing a bookish subject (in a book, of course....).
Then tonight I got halfway through David Weinberger's Small Pieces Loosely Joined (his follow-up to The Cluetrain Manifesto). That's good fun too, on a much broader canvas. A philosophy teacher turned software marketer turned web theorist, he takes a bunch of Big Concepts (time, space, that sort of stuff) & looks at how the web gives them an alternate meaning.
My favourite chapter so far is Perfection, where he argues persuasively & humourously that the web's 'brokenness' is its strength: its flaws are precisely what make it human & therefore attractive, overcoming corporate glossiness, political correctness & all the other little strategies used in the 'real world' to cover up our deep embarassment at failing to achieve perfection. Weinberger says it all far better than my summary!
4 Comments:
At 28 December, 2005 07:04, Bill said…
I found Eats, shoots and leaves OK, but I was disappointed with the numerous punctuation mistakes the book itself contains - pointed out by a New Yorker magazine article. The book loses effect and value with every error.
I also felt the layout was all wrong - wide margins, large typeface, and small pages gives a false impression of how many words you actually get.
On a positive note, the book has made me far more aware of punctuation.
At 28 December, 2005 11:27, bluefluff said…
Bill - interesting review, but I wonder if it referred to a duff US edition? My 2005 paperback doesn't seem to have these flaws (I checked a random selection of them)- indeed it doesn't even have the foreword that comes in for such scathing comment. Besides, what leaves a writer's keyboard is not necessarily what eventually appears on the printed page.
At 28 December, 2005 15:08, Bill said…
Perhaps it was just the original 2003 hardback and has since been corrected. As far as I know they went against publishing conventions and didn't make any changes to the US reprint.
I wanted two things from the book - a readable look at punctuation, and an accurate reference. It was certainly readable, but I lost faith in the accuracy. Even the front cover - the phrase "The Zero Tolerance Approach to Punctuation" - shouldn't that be "The Zero Tolerance Approach to Incorrect Punctuation"?
I'm probably just being a pedant as the book was a bestseller; and perhaps punctuation is becoming less important today...
At 30 December, 2005 18:26, kat said…
Small Pieces Loosely Joined
I've not read this book but as I am about to go shopping at amazon.co.uk.............. :-)
Eats, Shoots & Leaves
I read this some time ago and enjoyed the humour in it.
Post a Comment
<< Home